I’m knee-deep in editing my Kenan Fellowship lessons, but I wanted to share a couple of recent stories that should appeal to many Scripted readers.  Regular visitors will know that grading reform is one of my pet projects, and I follow news about it pretty closely.  This week, I came across two very interesting posts:

No-Zero Grading Policy In Lowndes County Schools Require Retesting Opportunities For Failing Students

This article from the Huffington Post’s Education section started off with some implied criticism of a large school system creating a “failures are not acceptable” approach.  However, a few days later, with feedback from the district leadership, the article was amended to make it clear that “no zeroes” does not mean that students will be automatically given passing grades.

I think that the story does a good job of bringing to light one of the more critical aspects of this grading reform: responsibility.  The district is taking responsibility for failing students, and taking a stand on allowing students to withdraw from their own education.  Many disagree with this stance, and these educators and pundits love to reminisce about a better time when families reinforced the importance of education at home and every student achieved at their highest potential… and they rode unicorns across rainbows to get to school each day.  These “good old days” never happened.  We simply chose to ignore those who failed to perform.

And now we refuse to do so.

 

3 Reasons Why School Districts Change Grading Practices

This article from Converge Magazine (the magazine of the Center for Digital Education), does a pretty good job of laying out the justification for many current standards-based grading systems.  The author uses the transition taking place in the Clear Creek Amana Community School District in Iowa as a model for what can be done to make grades more reflective of the learning taking place, and thereby serve as a more useful form of communication with parents and other stakeholders.

 

 

Read these and then tell me what you think.  Is grading reform turning a corner?

photo credit: victoriabernal via photopin cc

2 thoughts on “Grading in the News again

  1. Hi Paul,
    You asked, “Is grading reform turning a corner?

    Here in Iowa, I think it is. We had three Iowa legislators visit our district last week to learn about our grading practices and how it relates to the governor’s proposed education legislation. More information about their visit is available at bit.ly/wmAxgO

    I can’t speak for what’s going on across the country, but I think we’ve got a solid start here in the Hawkeye state!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s